D.L. Hughley on CNN
Monday, October 27th, 2008
Comedian D.L. Hughley has a new show on CNN. When I first heard about it I was both curious and anxious. It is a major coup for a black comedian to actually have a show on CNN. CNN is seen all over the world. I often marvel at how quickly my family in Nigeria get the US news, even before I do. If there is a tornado somewhere in the midwest, my father-in-law calls from Nigeria to see if we are fine, ever before we hear the news. So CNN has a major reach. To my knowledge, since Bernard Shaw, this would be the first really major African American to host his own talk show on the channel.
The first thing that I wondered was why was this slot not given to a serious African American news/talk person like Tavis Smiley? If you ever get a chance to listen to or watch Smiley on NPR or PBS, you know how seasoned and smooth he is as an interviewer. And there are others like him, such as Gwen Ifill, who consistently does such a great job with the vice-presidential debates. So why did CNN go with an African American comedian? I suppose the success of Jon Stewart and Stephen Colbert may have something to do with it. Another African American, David Greer, just premiered his own show, “Chocolate News,” on Comedy Central. I haven’t seen it but I read a review that said it was funny, though not quite as funny as Stewart and Colbert. Yet again, the standard has been set by the mainstream and African Americans are judged on those standards. That notwithstanding, the relevant point here is that these are comedy shows. People watch them and know they are infused with a heavy dose of humor and sarcasm.
This brings me to the reason why I was anxious about Hughley’s CNN show. The CNN audience is very different from the Comedy Central audience. For the most part, people tune in to CNN for the news, which comes with a very occasional smattering of chuckles provided by the dry back-and-forth between the anchors at the tail end of a show. I’m familiar with D.L. Hughley’s humor. It is neither occasional nor dry. It is sharp, direct, cynical, and often irreverent. Unlike cross-over comedians like Bill Cosby or Eddie Murphy, you have to know Hughley’s frame of reference to get the hilarity of his jokes. Would a general CNN audience be able to access the context that undergirds his work?
I came across the show, “D.L. Hughley Breaks the News,” over the weekend while I was flipping through channels. There he was, with a look on his face that immediately tickled me, but I was nervous. He had some serious guests, among them former Bush press secretary, Scott McClellan. Hughley asked McClellan to explain something further because he – Hughley – only had a GED. I laughed. So did McClelan, but he seemed a little uncomfortable. I’m sure he was wondering if it was “PC” for a white dude to be laughing with a black dude about his apparent lack of higher education. Then Hughley made a joke to the effect that the country must be in really bad shape if they are getting ready to vote in a black president. Again, this is funny; but for the straight-laced CNN audience, how literally would they take Hughley? Most of them don’t know of the long history of black comedy where black folks can laugh at themselves. I wondered, what if they take him literally? Seriously, I know a lot of folks, both here and abroad, who don’t get African American humor.
So, in the end I am left still nervous about Hughely on CNN. I’m glad he got a major show on a major network but I worry about how easily a mainstream audience will accept him. Television shows come and go rather swiftly (just ask Arsenio Hall!). So, regarding D.L. Hughley and CNN, we’ll just have to wait and see.